The Yankees face a real dilemma if they want to replace Clay Holmes as closer. Following a tough 3-2 loss to the Tigers on August 20, 2024, manager Aaron Boone was pressed on Holmes’ future in the role. Despite Holmes’ struggles, Boone indicated that he remains the team’s primary option, but changes may be necessary if his performance doesn’t improve.
Key takeaways:
- Holmes has 10 blown saves this season.
- Boone supports Holmes but hints at alternatives.
- The Yankees’ bullpen options are limited.
- Holmes has tied for sixth-most saves in MLB.
Yankees’ Closer Situation: Holmes’ Performance Under Scrutiny
Clay Holmes’ recent struggles have raised questions about his role as the Yankees’ closer. After blowing a save against the Tigers, manager Aaron Boone expressed support for Holmes but acknowledged the need to evaluate the situation as the season progresses. Boone emphasized that while Holmes has faced tough breaks, the team has several strong options in the bullpen. However, the effectiveness of these alternatives remains uncertain.
Potential Alternatives for Yankees’ Closer Role
As the Yankees consider their options, several pitchers could step in if Holmes is demoted. The team has limited experience in their bullpen, which raises concerns about reliability in high-pressure situations. Here are some potential alternatives:
- Lou Trivino: Has experience but limited saves this season.
- Ian Hamilton: Effective when healthy, but has few career saves.
- Tommy Kahnle: Tied for the most saves among current relievers.
Holmes’ Blown Saves and Performance Issues
Holmes has faced significant challenges this season, with 10 blown saves, including five against AL East rivals. His slider has been hit hard, with opponents batting .348 against it. Despite these struggles, he has collected 26 saves, tying him for sixth-most in MLB. The Yankees must weigh his experience against his recent performance when deciding on their closer strategy.
Impact of Decision on Yankees’ Playoff Prospects
As the Yankees approach the playoffs, the decision regarding their closer could have major implications. If Holmes continues to struggle, the team may need to pivot quickly to ensure they have a reliable option in high-stakes games. The effectiveness of their bullpen will be critical for their postseason success.
For more insights on the Yankees’ bullpen situation, visit [USA Today](https://www.usatoday.com) or [ESPN](https://www.espn.com). Keep an eye on updates as the season progresses.
